Pre-Combustion Chamber Apparatus and Method for Pre-Combustion

ABSTRACT

The present invention uses an improved engineered metal seal with or without an internal energized spring that is disposed in a pre-combustion chamber apparatus assembly to improve sealing over the flat washer seals that are currently used. The seals of the present invention comprise at least three different geometrical configurations of seals that are manufactured from titanium, Inconel, and/or hastelloy. The design of the tip and body of the pre-combustion chamber provide for movement of the seal without leaking. The sealing is provided on the axial surfaces of the tip and the body instead of the face of the tip and body by a flat washer seal, as is currently done.

CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a continuation of U.S. Pat. No. 6,893,027, filedJun. 4, 2020, which is a continuation of U.S. application Ser. No.14/834,401, filed Aug. 24, 2015, and thence to U.S. ProvisionalApplication No. 62/041,058 filed Aug. 23, 2014, each of which isincorporated by reference herein and made part of this specification.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION Field of the Invention (Technical Field)

The present invention relates to a seal apparatus and method of sealinga pre-combustion chamber comprising an improved sealing apparatus and animproved seal material. The several embodiments of the present inventionare disposed at both the combustion seal and the water jacket seal.

Currently used pre-combustion chamber assemblies are composed of adetachable tip (the pre-combustion chamber) that is sealed to apre-combustion chamber body where the two parts (tip and body) mate,using a flat washer type seal. The tip's function is to initiate thecombustion cycle in the engine cylinder. The flame front is ignited inthe rich environment of the tip and expands through holes in the tip toignite the fuel in the leaner cylinder combustion chamber environment.Due to seal failures, the Office of Environmental Management and othershave started welding the tip to the body as a method to eliminate sealleaks at the water jacket seal.

Currently some natural gas engines utilize a pre-combustion chamber tostart combustion in a relatively rich environment so that the flamefront can propagate in the leaner cylinder environment. Materialcompatibility and durability issues related to cyclic temperature andpressure changes in pre-combustion chambers are problematic. In additionto the material for the seals themselves, the materials used for thetip, chamber, and check valve may also fail.

Sealing surfaces of mating parts should have a good finish and as flat asurface as reasonably achievable to provide better sealing. Plating thesealing surfaces in a soft material such as copper may provide a lowerleak rate while requiring a less tight surface finish and a lowerflatness tolerance, depending on the material chosen for the seal.

Two important parameters affecting the quality of a seal obtained aresurface finish and flatness of the faces in contact with the seal. Apoor surface finish can provide leak paths past the seal, particularlyif tool marks produced by machining are radial rather thancircumferential. Likewise, a surface with poor flatness (i.e. wavy)presents a leak path if deflection of the seal material does not fillthe voids.

Currently used devices use copper-nickel metal gaskets to improve theseals. However, the present invention comprises engineered metal sealsand alternately comprises an internal energized spring. The presentinvention comprises these special geometry seals made from Inconel,titanium and/or hastalloy seals that withstand the high temperature andthe high cyclic pressures of combustion. The tip is currently made ofInconel alloy 625, and the seals currently in use are made of copper orcopper nickel alloys and are of a flat washer type design.

The present invention provides for improvements to seal geometry andtolerances, improved seal materials, and superior seal production. Thepresent invention provides improved tip surface finish and flatnessachieved in the machining operation, thus providing a better sealingsurface where the tip seals to the combustion chamber.

The present invention provides for movement of the tip and body matingparts and allows for movement of the seal without leaking.

One embodiment of the present invention provides for sealing on theaxial surfaces of the tip and body instead of the face of the tip andbody by a flat washer type seal, as is currently done.

One embodiment of the present invention provides for sealing on the faceof the tip to body connection, using an engineered metal seal with orwithout an energized internal spring.

The present invention provides the ability for the tip and sealconnection to continue to seal under the repeated hammering of thecombustion cycle, and will accommodate this at higher temperatures andpressures than the current pre-combustion chamber design. The new sealis designed to slide

along the axial connection of the tip to the body, so that as hammeringforces are applied the seal is not damaged as is the currently used flatwasher type seal.

The present invention also provides for a new and improved geometry ofboth the pre-combustion chamber tip and pre-combustion body wherein aspring energized c-ring seal is disposed in the energized metal seal.The present invention comprises a preferred embodiment and alternativeembodiments comprising spring energized seals of a plurality ofgeometries, including the “C” ring geometry.

One embodiment of the present invention comprising a seal provides for aface to face seal that seals the end face of the tip to the mating faceof the body where the parts join. One embodiment of the presentinvention comprising a seal provides for a seal that seals the outsidediameter of the body to the inside diameter of the tip where the partsmate.

The present invention provides for a replacement pre-combustion chamberwith a detachable tip which can be replaced separately, drasticallylowering the overall cost to users. The present invention provides for areplacement chamber comprising an improved part geometry, improvedmaterials selection and gasket/sealing surface design.

The present invention provides for a replacement chamber with increasedreliability of the tip-to-body-seal, comprising both improvements to theexisting seal design for better performance, also applicable to the tipto combustion chamber seal, as well as to modify the tip and chamberbody design wherein a more robust type of seal is disposed.

The apparatus and method of the present invention overcomes thedeficiencies of the devices and methods currently used because themethod is straightforward and elegant and results in significantlyimproved performance of the pre-combustion chamber. The apparatus andmethod of the present invention comprises an engineered metal seal withoptional installed spring energized seal disposed axially or alternatelyin a full groove disposed in the pre-ignition chamber body and/or tip,with additional changes made to certain part configurations to enhanceperformance of the combustion chamber.

This apparatus may also be applied to the combustion seal, where the Tipenters the main engine combustion chamber (engine cylinder). In thisapplication, the present invention would seal the outside diameter ofthe Tip to the inside diameter of the main combustion chamber, oralternately be placed in a groove on the face of the Tip combustion sealsurface and would mate to the current in use combustion seal surface onthe main combustion chamber. The size of the seal and location may vary.

In summary, the present invention provides for a modified tip to chamberbody seal comprising modification of the interface between the tip andchamber body to accept a spring energized C-ring seal that results in areduced leak rate.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

The present invention comprises a pre-combustion chamber assemblycomprising a body shaft, a tip, a seal disposed on axial surfaces ofsaid tip and said body shaft, and a groove disposed in said body shaft,wherein the seal comprises an engineered metal seal, an engineered metalseal with an energized spring, or a face style engineered metal seal andan energized spring. Insertion of the tip is aligned by the presence andorientation of the groove.

The engineered metal seal comprises a material including Inconel,hastelloy, or titanium alloys.

The axial surface on the outer diameter of the body shaft comprises aplurality of tapers.

The present invention comprises a method for sealing pre-combustionchamber assembly comprising disposing a groove in a pre-combustionchamber, inserting a seal comprising an engineered metal seal in thegroove, and improving the geometry and tolerances of the ignitionpre-chamber.

The method further comprises disposing the seal against the radialsurface of the body shaft and the tip. The method further comprisesaligning and seating the seal. Aligning the seal comprises disposing anengineered metal seal along the body shaft wherein the body shaftcomprises increasing diameters by providing tapered sections.

The method of sealing further comprises expanding the seal against thebody shaft, increasing the pressure of the seal at one face of the bodyshaft, and thus increasing sealing properties.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE SEVERAL VIEWS OF THE DRAWINGS

The accompanying drawings in the attachment, which are incorporated intoand form a part of the specification, illustrate one or more embodimentsof the present invention and, together with the description, serve toexplain the principles of the invention. The drawings are only for thepurpose of illustrating one or more preferred embodiments of theinvention and are not to be construed as limiting the invention. In thedrawings:

FIG. 1 is a cross section view of the preferred embodiment of thepre-combustion chamber;

FIG. 2 is a side view of the pre-combustion chamber assembly of thepresent invention;

FIG. 3 is a cross-section view of an alternate embodiment of thepre-combustion chamber assembly of the present invention;

FIG. 4A is a detail view illustrating an enlarged view of the body shaftshown in FIG. 3;

FIG. 4B is a cross section view of the tip element of the alternateembodiment of the pre-combustion chamber assembly of the presentinvention illustrated in FIG. 3;

FIG. 5 is a detail view of the tip element sealing surfaces illustratedin FIGS. 4A and 48;

FIG. 6 is a cross section view of the seal assembly mechanism;

FIG. 7 illustrates a cross section view of the spring energized metalseal of the present invention;

FIG. 8 is a top view of a metal seal;

FIG. 9 is a cross section view of the “C” engineered metal seal;

FIG. 10 illustrates the body shaft element of the pre-combustion chamberassembly of the present invention;

FIG. 11 is a cross section view of the seal assembly of the presentinvention;

FIG. 12 is a top view of an energized metal seal;

FIG. 13 is a cross section view the energized metal seal illustrated inFIG. 12;

FIG. 14 is a cross section view of the assembly seal mechanism of thepresent invention;

FIG. 15 is a graph illustrating the plastic deformation of the thicknessof the combustion chamber gasket of the present invention;

FIG. 16 is a graph illustrating the plastic deformation of the thicknessof the combustion chamber gasket of the present invention;

FIG. 17 is a graph illustrating the plastic deformation of the tip tocombustion chamber gasket of the present invention;

FIG. 18 is a graph illustrating the plastic deformation of the tip tocombustion chamber gasket of the present invention;

FIG. 19 illustrates an Ashby plot, plotting yield strength vs. Young'smodulus;

FIG. 20 illustrates an Ashby plot of modulus vs. yield strength for thecombustion chamber gasket replacement material;

FIG. 21 illustrates an Ashby plot of fracture toughness vs. maximumservice temperature; and

FIG. 22 illustrates an Ashby plot of thermal expansion coefficient vs.price.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

The present invention addresses and improves on deficiencies in devicescurrently used. Currently, seals disposed between the tip and the baseof the combustion chamber leak and therefore either fail completely or acomplete burn is not achieved. Natural gas mixes with coolant if theseal between the glycol coolant area and the combustion chamber leaks.This mixture burns at a higher temperature, resulting in materialsperformance issues, causing the seals to work less efficiently, reducingtip life, and leading to potential catastrophic failure. The presentinvention provides an improved seal that overcomes the followingdeficiencies. Seals made of soft material plastically deform due tocyclic loading of combustion pressure and thermal cycling, creating leakpaths. Seals made of hard materials do not seal. Surface imperfectionsprovide leak paths and potential uneven seating load.

The present invention provides for an improved seal design for the tipto chamber body seal comprising a plurality of Engineered Metal Sealswith optional energized springs. These seals may be configured to beused either axially or as face seals. The preferred embodiment is aC-ring geometry consisting of a plated ‘C’ shaped metal jacket over aclose-wound helical spring coil core. The spring and jacket are made ofa high temperature, high strength alloy such as Inconel Alloy 625, Alloy718, or or Alloy X750, or Hastelloy or Rene 41 or other such hightemperature materials, and the jacket is plated with a soft materialsuch as silver or copper or gold. The plating provides a ductile outerlayer to fill surface imperfections and the jacket material, internalspring, and gas pressure force provide a high seating force with goodelasticity. The present invention comprises an improved seal and amodification of the mating parts geometry, making adjustments to improvethe performance of existing

metal seal. The plating also provides for an inert metal covering on theseal to reduce carbon and other deposit build up due to the reactionbetween the sulfur typically found in natural gas and the unplatedmetals.

The spring coils work independently of one another so slight deviationsin surface flatness are tolerated. The seals are installed with adeflection-limiting feature configured similar to an 0-ring groove,resulting in loading beyond the seating load of the seal being carriedby the mating parts, and not the seal itself.

The placement and design of pre-combustion chambers currently used inengines are susceptible to impact forces that are created whencombustion occurs inside the piston. This combustion explosion causesforces to be transmitted back against the pre-combustion chamber andresults in significant impact to the seal and mating seal surfacescurrently used. This results in deformation of the seal and or sealsurfaces, leading to loss of compression at the seal surface, and leaks.Both embodiments of the present invention overcome these deficiencies.

We refer now to the Figures. FIG. 1 is a cross section view of oneembodiment of a pre-combustion chamber assembly, comprising flat washertype seal 2. Pre-combustion chamber assembly 1 also comprises tip 4 andbody 6. The method of assembly of the pre-combustion chamber assemblycomprises the following steps. The washer type seal slides over the bodyshaft and the tip then slides over the body shaft. The face of the tipand the body shaft are sealed when the assembly is installed in theengine. Two bolts are used to apply pressure from the back end of thepre-combustion chamber, pressing the assembly against the combustionseal surface of the main combustion chamber. During this process the tipand body face are squeezed together forming a seal between the tip andbody shaft. Pressurized natural gas is injected into the pre-combustionchamber and separately into the engine cylinder. A spark plug providesthe initial ignition to the gas inside the pre-combustion chamber. Whenthe gas in the pre-combustion chamber is ignited, flame shoots out thethe end of the pre-combustion chamber tip and into the main combustionchamber, causing cylinder combustion.

The force of detonation is transmitted back to the pre-combustionchamber and its components including the seals.

In FIG. 1, lip 5 is disposed on tip 4, comprising the maximum diameterthat fits into a cylinder. Surface 3 is the end of body 6. A moredetailed description of this embodiment of the present invention will befound after the description of the preferred embodiment which followsimmediately herein.

FIG. 2 is a cross section side view of the preferred embodiment of thepre-combustion chamber assembly of the present invention. This preferredembodiment of the pre-combustion chamber assembly 10 comprisesengineered metal seal 8, body 9, tip 7, and engineered metal radialshaft seal 8. This preferred embodiment of the present inventioncomprises three embodiments of engineered metal seals all of whichprovide a method of sealing that is an improvement over the sealingpresently known. Two of the seal embodiments comprise engineered metalradial shaft seal 8 comprising engineered metal seal with energizedspring 34 illustrated in FIG. 7 and engineered metal seal 35 illustratedin FIG. 6. The present invention also comprises face style engineeredmetal seal with energized spring 47 shown in FIG. 14.

The preferred embodiment of the present invention comprises amodification of the interface configuration between the tip and thechamber body that is currently used in order to house the springenergized C-ring seal that results in improved performance andlongevity. Ductile plating material, such as copper, fills surfaceimperfections while the spring, jacket, and pressure forces provide ahigh elastic seating load, resulting in a resilient seal with a low leakrate. The preferred embodiment seal of the present invention is lesssusceptible to cyclic loading than a sealing washer since the seal isdisposed and contained within a groove, as long as deflection of thegroove is kept to a minimum. The current invention comprises a designthat incorporates the groove into the pre-ignition chamber body. Stressanalysis results indicate that this configuration is strong enough toperform with the clamping load and cyclic combustion chamber pressureforce expected.

The preferred embodiment is the “C” geometry, axial type seal with orwithout internal energized spring. The present invention comprises amodification of the interface configuration between the tip and thechamber body that is currently used in order to house the C-ring sealthat results in improved performance and longevity. Ductile platingmaterial, such as copper, silver or gold fills the surface imperfectionswhile the spring, jacket, and pressure forces of combustion provide ahigh elastic seating load, resulting in a resilient seal with a low leakrate. The seal of the present invention is less susceptible to cyclicloading than a sealing washer since the engineered metal seal isdesigned to accept movement, and will not deform under the loads andpressures applied on the pre-combustion chamber, during engineoperation, as does the current seal.

For face to face type seals, the current invention comprises a designthat incorporates a groove into the pre-ignition chamber body. Stressanalysis results indicate that this configuration is strong enough toperform with the clamping load and cyclic combustion chamber pressureforce expected.

FIG. 3 is a cross-section view of the embodiment of the pre-combustionchamber assembly of the present invention shown in FIG. 2, illustratingthe pre-combustion chamber body 9 with no tip 7 or engineered metal seal8 installed. The area 17 where engineered metal seal 8 is installed isshown in FIG. 4A. This is an example of the machining required on thebody for the installation of a “C” style engineered metal seal, thepreferred embodiment. This figure shows in more detail where on the bodythe seal is installed. This is a view of the preferred embodiment of theinvention.

FIG. 4A is a detail view illustrating an enlarged view of the body shaftshown in FIG. 3 in the area marked “FIG. 4.” FIG. 4A shows a portion ofpre-combustion chamber body shaft 17 comprising engineered metal seal 8and tip 7 and illustrating the installation of a plurality of elementsand the design of this portion of the present invention. All surfaces ofbody shaft 17 are smooth, straight, round, and perpendicular to thecenterline of body 9. In the construction of the present invention,tooling marks are radial to the diameter of the body shaft, and themachining surface finish is a minimum of 32 root mean square (RMS.)

The diameter of body shaft 11 is a maximum 0.013 inches less that theinside diameter of whatever seal is used. Thus, engineered metal seal 8easily slides onto the body shaft. The designed fit is sufficientlyclose ensuring that the engineered metal seal remains adequatelyperpendicular to the body shaft, insuring a proper fit and alignment ofthe engineered metal seal during the initial phase of installation.

As engineered metal seal 8 installation is disposed along body shaft 17,the body shaft diameter increases due to the disposition of taper area12 comprising a taper of 0.040 by 15 degrees. Taper area 12 is atransition to surface of body shaft 13, providing for incrementaltightening of the fit between the body shaft and engineered metal seal8, which provides a mechanism to maintain alignment and perpendicularityof engineered metal seal 8 related to body shaft 17 as installationprogresses.

The outside diameter of the body shaft comprises the surface whereengineered metal seal 8 is ultimately seated. This diameter is1.479-1.489 inches and said dimension is tightly controlled. At thispoint the body shaft diameter at body shaft radial surface 13 is largerthan inside diameter 37 (shown in FIG. 8) of engineered metal seal 8thus providing for both “C” geometrical shape 38 (shown in FIG. 9) ofengineered metal seal 8 and providing for the designed spring temper ofthe engineered metal seal to be interference fitted over body shaft 13with a specific designed force value.

Engineered metal seal 8 and the design of engineered metal seal 8provides spring tension against body shaft radial surface 13 and alsoagainst tip diameter 24 where engineered metal seal 8 mates to tip 7.Sealing assembly mechanism 44 (shown in FIG. 11) thus provides bettersealing properties for the pre-combustion chamber's exposure to severeoperating conditions. The seal is properly spring tempered, and thematerial of engineered metal seal 8 withstands the extreme operatingtemperatures, combustion pressure, and repeated combustion shock (i.e.hammering) that are experienced during normal engine operation.

The bottom radius of the “C” of engineered metal seal 8 seats at onebottom area of body shaft surface 13. Body shaft 17 comprises anotherradius provided by machining into face 14, where engineered metal sealcomprising “C” geometrical shape 38 seats. Thus, the preferredembodiment of the present invention provides for the proper seating andalignment of engineered metal seal 8.

Additional sealing surface area where the bottom of engineered metalseal 8 seats to body shaft 17 is provided at face 14. The method of useof the present invention provides, during combustion, the force ofcombustion gases to impact the open end of “C” element 23 (shown in FIG.5) of engineered metal seal 8, thus disposing the sides and the bottomradius of engineered metal seal 8 to expand against the sealing surfacesof body shaft 17 at body shaft radial surface 13, thus increasingpressure of engineered metal seal 8 against body shaft radial surface 13at the bottom of the body shaft at face 14 to increase the sealingproperties of the mechanism. The configuration of the present inventionprovides for retention of engineered metal seal 8 to body shaft 17during removal of tip 7 during any subsequent tip 7 and seal 8replacement.

Area 15 of body shaft 17 comprises a 0.005 radius that blends into the1.646-1.649 diameter of body shaft 17 providing a smooth fit of tip 7 tobody 9. The present invention comprises 0.005 inches of clearancebetween body shaft 17 and tip 9, ensuring proper alignment duringinstallation, and ensuring installation of tip 9 in a downwarddisposition, and also insuring that the tip does not damage engineeredmetal seal 8 during installation of tip 9 over engineered metal seal 8.The geometry of tip 7 is also similarly designed and is illustrated inFIG. 48.

Seating surface 16 comprises a face of tip 7 that is disposed adjacentto the face of body shaft 17. The present invention provides a precisevertical fit of tip 7 to body 9 (vertically) providing a properlylocated and aligned disposition of engineered metal seal 8 to both body9 and tip 7.

Sealing assembly mechanism 44 (shown in FIG. 11) comprising engineeredmetal seal 8 and body shaft 17 provides adequate movement duringoperation and also maintains an adequate seal. The fit combined with thespecified dimensions and tolerances of the present invention, results ina significantly improved sealing mechanism and improved life of the sealin all operating conditions. A cross section view of the assembly of tip7, engineered metal seal 8, and body 9 is shown in FIG. 5.

FIG. 4B is a cross section view of the tip element of the alternateembodiment of the pre-combustion chamber assembly of the presentinvention illustrated in FIG. 3. This view shows a cross section view oftip 7. The encircled area 18 is shown as a detail view in FIG. 5.

FIG. 5 is a detail view of area 18 enlarging the area shown in FIG. 48in order to see details. This figure shows a cross section view of tip 7illustrating how tip 7 is aligned with and disposed on engineered metalseal 8 and body shaft 17. A detailed cross section view of seal assemblymechanism 44 comprising tip 7, body 9, and engineered metal seal 8 areillustrated in FIG. 11. Tapered relief cut 20 is provided so that whentip 7 is disposed on body shaft 17, this feature provides for tip 7 toalign with body shaft 17. Area 21 is a tightly controlled dimensionalrelief providing for easy installation of tip 7 to body 9, whilemaintaining clearance and fit for seal 8 to tip 7.

Additional relief taper cut 22 provides for improved installation andalignment of tip 7 as the tip moves along body shaft 17 toward seal 8during installation during installation of the tip to the body shaft.Surface area 23 provides a pocket of free area so that tip 7 does notcontact the top of seal 8, providing a gap that ensures that the top ofseal 8 is not contacted, and thus the geometric “C” of the seal 8 is notdeformed. The gap also provides for combustion gas to penetrate the gapbetween tip 7 and seal 8, so that it directly impacts the open end ofthe “C” forcing seal surface 40 (seen in FIG. 9) against tip 7 at radialsurface area 24 and the body shaft at face 13 and face 14 (both seen inFIG. 4a ), improving and insuring sealing properties.

Radial surface area 24 comprises an area where seal 8 mates and sealsagainst the inside diameter of tip 7. This dimension is tightlycontrolled to insure proper fit, proper alignment, and the best possiblesealing properties. This area has very stringent dimensional controls,i.e. a minimum of 32 RMS surface finish, and radial (not longitudinal)tool marks only. All of this is part of the seal design of the presentinvention. RMS is a method to measure surface finish on metal, asdescribed in ASME 846.1. Ra is the arithmetic average of the absolutevalues of the profile height deviations from the mean line, recordedwithin the evaluation length, simply put it is the average of a set ofindividual measurements of surfaces peaks and valleys.

Additional designed taper 25 aligns tip 7 as it is initially disposed onseal 8 during installation. This design ensures that tip 7 does notnegatively impact seal 8 as it is disposed. Taper design 25 ensures tip7 is properly aligned with seal 8 and ensures the pressure of tip 7against seal 8 is uniform and equal during installation, so that the “C”design or configuration of seal 8 compresses in a uniform and equalmanner around the entire diameter during assembly.

Relief groove 26 is machined into tip 7 and additionally ensures properinstallation as tip 7 is disposed adjacent to seal S. Groove 26 providesa mechanism for tip 7 to move over seal 8 with an improved fit beforethe interference fit is encountered as tip 7 slides progressively downover seal 8 during assembly. Groove 26 also allows for smoother andeasier installation of tip 7 onto body shaft 17, after it passes seal 8,on its path to the final seating face of seating surface 16 to bodyshaft 17.

Surface area 27's dimensions are tightly controlled to insure proper fitof tip 7 to body 9 as tip 7 is fitted to its final vertical locationwhere seating surface 16 (see FIG. 4A) meets body shaft 17 (see FIG.4A). This fit and location are critical to insure the proper location oftip 7, body 9 and seal 8 into the assembly.

FIG. 6 is a cross section view of seal assembly mechanism 54 comprisingtip 7, engineered metal seal 35, and body 9. This view shows thedisposition of “C” engineered metal seal 35, not showing the internalenergized wound spring. Sealing assembly mechanism 54 (also seen in FIG.14) comprises tip 7, body 9, and seal 8 so that the elements worktogether as a system to provide a significantly improved seal that isimproved over seals currently used. FIG. 6 includes elements previouslydescribed and illustrated in other figures, such as body shaft 17, thediameter of body shaft 11, taper area 12, surface of body shaft 13, face14, area 15, seating surface 16, etc. seen in FIGS. 4A and 5.

FIG. 7 illustrates a cross section view of the spring energized metalseal of the present invention. This is a cross section view of springenergized engineered metal seal 34 disposed with internal woundenergized spring 29. This version of engineered metal seal 34 iscomprised of the “C” engineered metal seal assembly mechanism 44 shownin FIG. 11, with added internal wound spring 29 that is disposed in the“C” section of engineered metal seal 44, thus comprising springenergized engineered metal seal 34.

Wound spring 29 is disposed in the “C” section of the engineered metalseal. Spring 29 maintains outward force against the sides of the “C”section of the seal. This spring force works to maintain constant forceof the seal to the mating surfaces of both body shaft 17 and the tipsealing surface. The winding of the spring has openings so thatcombustion gas can pass through it allowing the combustion gas to alsoprovide additional outward pressure, forcing the seal against the matingsurfaces.

“C” engineered metal seal 30 acts as the casing for sound spring 29.Outside radius 31 of “C” engineered metal seal 30 also comprises theradius area that is specified and designed to mate to groove 14 (shownin FIG. 4A) that is cut into the face of body shaft 17. This outsideradius design allows for more surface contact area where engineeredmetal seal 8 meets body shaft 17 face sealing area at groove 14. Thisdesign promotes greater seal surface area and thus greater combustionpressure forces against seal 8 and to the body shaft at groove 14 duringcombustion, due to the forces of combustion gas pressures against theseal. Area 32 is where the seal contacts and seals against tip 7 on itsinside diameter 24. Within the same 30 degree specified area of surface33 is where engineered metal seal 8 contacts and seals against bodyshaft 17 at face 13.

FIG. 8 is a top view of a metal seal. FIG. 8 illustrates a top view of“C” engineered metal seal 35 without an energized spring. Outsidediameter surface 36 of engineered metal seal 35 contacts the sealingsurface of the tip. Inside diameter 37 of engineered metal seal 35contacts the body shaft 17 at face 13.

FIG. 9 is a cross section view of “C” engineered metal seal 35, withoutthe energized internal spring comprising designed outside diametersurface 38 and the geometry of the “C” seal. The perimeter of thisoutside diameter surface is the sealing contact area against body shaft17 and tip 7. This design allows for many design benefits, including butnot limited to allowing seal 35 to flex like a spring under load. Thedesign provides for increased sealing surface area because by the designmore surface contact area is created. The “C” shape and spring temperprovide for combustion gasses to force the seal against the mating partswith increased pressure which provides an increased seal due to thecombustion loads applied.

Designed inside diameter surface 39 of the “C” seal provides the maximumspring benefit against the sealing surfaces. When the energized woundspring is added to the design, this is where it is installed. Designedcontact area 40 provides for mating of engineered metal seal 35 to tip7, and opposite this area on the other side of the “C” is whereengineered metal seal 35 mates to body shaft 17.

FIG. 10 illustrates body shaft 17 of the pre-combustion chamber assemblyof the present invention. This view shows the re-location of the groovein the body shaft that is used to properly orient the tip. Thismodification is an improvement that is necessary to accommodate facetype engineered metal seal 47 (shown in FIG. 14) due to an interferenceproblem created when machining the required sealing surfaces into theoriginal of the alternate embodiment of the pre-combustion chamberassembly. Without this design modification, face type engineered metalseal 47 cannot be used on the pre-combustion chamber. New location 41 ofthe groove and former location 42 of the groove are shown in thisfigure.

FIG. 11 is a cross section view of the seal assembly of the presentinvention. FIG. 11 illustrates a cross section view of seal assemblymechanism 44 comprising internal wound energized spring seal 34, area 18(shown in FIG. 48 and FIG. 5), and shaft body 17. The other elements areshown in other Figures herein.

FIG. 12 is a top view of “C” energized metal seal 34 comprising “C” typeengineered metal seal 35 and internal wound energized spring 29.

FIG. 13 is a cross section view of the energized metal seal illustratedin FIG. 12. FIG. 13 illustrates a cross section view of “C” typeenergized metal seal 35 comprising an internal wound energized spring,seal contact area 32 disposed between the engineered metal seal and thetip, “C” engineered metal seal 35 and wound energized spring 29.

FIG. 14 illustrates a cross section view of the assembly seal mechanism54 comprising spring energized engineered metal face seal 47. Element 49is a cross section view of the shaft body where the groove 52 to 53 ismachined into the face of body shaft 17. Location 50 is the area ofcompression that is generated when the tip is compressed against theshaft body during installation. Location 52 is the width specificationof the groove that contains face type engineered metal seal 47. Location53 is the depth specification of the groove disposed in body shaft 17that contains face type engineered metal seal 47.

The method of use of the alternate embodiment of the present inventioncomprising plated C-ring shaft seal comprising a close-wound helicalspring core results in providing increased working pressure greater than20,000 psi. Plating provides a ductile outer layer to fill surfaceimperfections for a better seal and more economical manufacturing cost.Plated C-ring shaft seal also provides an improved base material with aninternal spring and continuous positive pressure providing improvedseating force and improved elasticity to accommodate joint movement.Plated C-ring shaft seal comprises spring coils that work independentlyof one another, compensating for any slight deviations in surfaceflatness.

Using a seal that seals on the shaft, i.e. the outside diameter of thechamber body, and/or the inside diameter of the tip reduces the forces,pressure and cyclic loading on the seal. During combustion the forcescreated are in alignment with the shaft and parallel to the tip andbody, so these forces are not absorbed by the seal, and thus the seal isless susceptible to deformation, and the life and performance of theseal is increased. Thermal cycling and cyclic loading from combustionare carried by mating parts, not the seal itself because the presentinvention provides for adding a groove for the seal to be disposed, thuslimiting deflection. The seal of the present invention provides for alower leak rate than other types of seals currently in use.

Sealing the tip to body on the inside diameter of the tip to the outsidediameter of the body in both embodiments of the present inventionprovides for an improvement to seals currently used. Previous designsused only a seal on the face of the two parts or a seal on both the faceand the diameter together.

The tip is modified with a shoulder on its outer diameter and a step onthe inner diameter for an improved slip fit onto the chamber body.Specifications for the slip fit are driven by several factors.

Thermal expansion between the tip and body materials is considered.Another consideration is the dead volume contained in the clearancebetween the parts. Crevice volumes in the combustion chamber are knownto be a major source of unburned hydrocarbon emissions. If the clearancebetween the tip and body is sufficiently large, the flame will be ableto propagate through the dead volume, and minimal contribution tounburned hydrocarbons would be expected. As the gap is decreased, therewill be a point at which the flame quenches at the crevice entrance.This gap corresponds to a maximum contribution to hydrocarbon emissions.The present invention's improved configuration and dimensions result ingaps smaller than this threshold, resulting in a lower contribution tohydrocarbon emissions due to the reduction in dead volume.

The chamber body is modified by elongating the sealing face by addingaxial length. The tip is modified by adding a counterbore to accept thespring energized C-ring seal. A shoulder is added to the outer diameterof the tip.

Use of a small gap rather than one large enough for flame propagationensures consistent positioning of the tip on the body and results inlower temperature demands on the seal while minimizing the dead volumeavailable for generation of unburned hydrocarbon emissions. The seal ofthe present invention is less susceptible to cyclic loading than awasher since the seal is contained within a groove, as long asdeflection of the groove is kept to a minimum. The design of the presentinvention results in minimal deflection of the groove due to combustionchamber pressure. The present invention seal configuration is alsostrong enough to perform with the expected clamping load and cycliccombustion chamber pressure force.

Combining a high temperature material like Inconel 718 with an energizedseal, where the seal is also copper plated, and using a high temperaturematerial in the ignition pre-chamber, in the groove, and with improvedgeometry and tolerances creates an improved apparatus and method ofsealing the parts of the apparatus of the present invention.

Material compatibility and durability issues related to cyclictemperature and pressure changes were considered. In addition to thematerial for the seals themselves, the materials used for the tip,chamber, and check valve were also reviewed.

Example 1: C-Ring Seal Materials

Since current gasket type seals lose their hardness and deform due tothermal and cyclic loading, the C-ring type seals used here were not assusceptible to loss of hardness due to the thermal and cyclic loading ofthe parts during combustion cycling.

The C-ring seals of the present invention used Inconel, titanium and orother high temperature tolerant materials that provided better strengthand wear characteristics at high service temperatures. Inconel 718,Inconel 754, Inconel 625, and Ti-15Mo-3Al-3Nb provided a higher servicetemperature, improved wear characteristics at high service temperatures,a higher toughness at all temperature ranges, and higher temperaturetolerance than the current seal materials being used.

Example 2: Stress Analysis

Stress analysis results indicated that the seal configuration of thepresent invention is strong enough to perform with the clamping load andcyclic combustion chamber pressure force expected. Using the tipdimensions of 1.86″ outer diameter and 1.47″ inner diameter, thiscorresponds to around 25.5 ksi (kilograms/square inch) stress which mustbe carried by the seal material. Similarly, for the tip to combustionchamber seal, using 1.85″ inner diameter and 2.125″ outer diameter, theseal must carry around 30.3 ksi. The magnitude of cyclic loading on thepre-ignition chamber to tip seal due to engine cylinder pressure wasestimated assuming a 1,500 psig (pounds/square inch gage) peak cylinderpressure acting equally on all exposed faces within the tip, up to thesealing washer and check valve. The main effect was determined to bethat the load carried through the seal is reduced as the pressure forceacts on the face of the chamber body.

Based on the 1.47″ ID of the tip, 1,500 psi amounts to around 2,500 lbf(pounds force) of fluctuation. With the bolt clamp load putting the sealnear the yield strength of copper-nickel alloys, plastic deformation ofthe seal under this cyclic loading is not surprising. Obtaining a goodseal requires that imperfections in surface finish and flatness arefilled by the seal material. For this reason, a material with lowelastic modulus but high yield strength was determined to be suitablefor the present invention. Given the cyclic loading seen by these seals,a yield strength of at least 40 ksi was determined to be required.

Example 3: Gasket Materials

Dimensions of used and new gaskets were measured with a micrometer tomeasure whether plastic deformation was occurring during service. FIG.15 is a graph illustrating the plastic deformation of the thickness ofthe combustion chamber gasket of the present invention. FIG. 16 is agraph illustrating the plastic deformation of the thickness of thecombustion chamber gasket of the present invention. These Figuresillustrate gasket dimension measurements completed in this study. Inaddition to the data plotted in FIGS. 15 and 16, the width and diameterof currently used gaskets were both found to increase during service,indicating that the gasket is essentially forged to a thinner, widershape during service.

Additionally, the approximate hardness of the tip to chamber usedgaskets were determined to be 89 Vickers, while the new tip to chambergaskets were found to be 115 Vickers. This indicates that the moderatelyhigh (−400° F.) exposure temperatures were lowering the strength of thecurrently used copper-nickel (Cu—Ni) gaskets.

Although plastically deforming gaskets by crushing can be a method usedto get them to seal properly, in an environment subjected to vibrationor cyclic loading, elastic deformation which can accommodate the dynamicstrains is preferable. To this end, materials with a higher strength andlower modulus than the current 70/30 Cu Ni mix are desirable. Theexperiments described herein have led to preferable seal materials.

Granta's CES Selector software using the Material Universe database wasused to provide the data and plots for the following materials selectionexercises.

Materials were filtered by those which had a maximum service temperatureabove 400° F., the expected temperature at the gasket position, and acost less than $15.00/lb.

FIG. 19 illustrates an Ashby plot, plotting yield strength vs. Young'smodulus that was generated showing potential replacement materials forthe tip to chamber seal. Desired properties of the seal are higherstrength and lower modulus. This plot includes materials with a maximumservice temperature greater than 400° F. FIG. 18 illustrates that amongthese types of materials, 70/30 copper-nickel has quite a high modulusand low strength. Its strength is merely half of the 40 ksi recommendeddue to stress analysis experiments reported in Example 1. The variousalloys are colored according to their major constituents. All of thecopper alloys are too weak. INVAR and thoria dispersed Ni are strongenough, although their modulus remains rather high. The best options areTitanium alloys, which have lower moduli and high strength.

A similar analysis was performed on the combustion chamber gasket,currently made from Monel 404. The width has increased in the usedgaskets as shown in FIG. 15. The initial approximate hardness of theMonel gasket was 177 Vickers, while the used gaskets averaged around 140Vickers hardness. The upper gasket experiences much higher temperaturesthan the tip to chamber gasket, in excess of 1100° F.

A similar materials selection exercise was done for the combustionchamber seal, but with the minimum temperature of this portion of theapparatus set at 1100° F. and cost set below $40/lb, it was determinedthat Ni alloys, Ti alloys, and Fe alloys, as well as a couple ofceramics which would be too brittle for the application would work well.Materials with fracture toughness lower than 50 ksi/square inch wereremoved from the Ashby plot shown in FIG. 20. FIG. 20 illustrates anAshby plot of modulus vs. yield strength for the combustion chambergasket replacement material.

FIG. 21 illustrates an Ashby plot of fracture toughness vs. maximumservice temperature illustrating that preferred materials have similaror higher toughness and higher temperature tolerance than currently usedmaterials.

FIG. 22 illustrates an Ashby plot of thermal expansion coefficient vs.price of materials. Desired properties are low modulus, high strength,and low cost. Nickel and titanium alloys exhibit the preferred qualityof lower thermal expansion coefficient than currently used coppergaskets.

The present invention provides for an improved seal design for the tipto chamber body seal comprising a plurality of spring energized metalC-rings. The C-ring consists of a plated ‘C’ shaped metal jacket over aclose-wound helical spring coil core. The spring and jacket are made ofa high temperature, high strength alloy such as Inconel Alloy 625, Alloy718, or Alloy X750, and the jacket is plated with a soft material suchas silver or copper. The plating provides a ductile outer layer to fillsurface imperfections and the jacket material, internal spring, and gaspressure force provide a high seating force with good elasticity.

The spring coils work independently of one another so slight deviationsin surface flatness are tolerated. The seals are installed with adeflection-limiting feature configured similar to an 0-ring groove,resulting in loading beyond the seating load of the seal being carriedby the mating parts, and not the seal itself.

The placement and design of pre-combustion chambers currently used inengines are susceptible to impact forces that are created whencombustion occurs inside the piston. This combustion explosion causesforces to be transmitted back against the pre-combustion chamber andresults in significant impact to the seal and mating seal surfacescurrently used. This results in deformation of the seal and or sealsurfaces, leading to loss of compression at the seal surface, and leaks.Both embodiments of the present invention overcome these deficiencies.

In conclusion, there are thus four mechanisms that provide directpressure of the seal of the present invention to the mating surfaces,i.e. (a) the interference fit, (b) the spring action of the “C”geometry, (c) the spring temper of the heat treat applied to the “C”geometry, (d) the internal wound spring pushing out and up against the“C” seal, and (e) the combustion pressure that feeds into the topopening of the “C”, which pushes the interior of the C geometry out andagainst the mating surfaces.

Other considerations comprise the use of new materials including but notlimited to Haynes 242 per AMS 5951 and Rene 41 to the list of sealmaterials. Optional copper plating, optional silver plating, and/oroptional gold plating add to sealing properties because of the use ofsoft metals, adding to corrosion resistance.

Use new internal spring materials comprising Inconel materials includingHastelloy C-276 per UNS N10276.

Add new design of the face of engineered metal seals of all geometriesand both with and without energized springs, as well as the design ofthe radial shaft sealing style and using engineered metal seals of allgeometries both with and without energized springs.

Although the invention has been described in detail with particularreference to these preferred embodiments, other embodiments can achievethe same results. Variations and modifications of the present inventionare obvious to those skilled in the art and it is intended to cover allsuch modifications and equivalents.

What is claimed is:
 1. A pre-combustion chamber assembly, comprising:(a) a sealing member ring having an inner diameter, a cross-sectionhaving a width and a height, and an outer diameter equal to the innerdiameter plus two times the width of the cross-section, where thecross-section is open in a direction perpendicular to a plane formed bythe diameter of the ring; (b) a body, having a cylindrical end portionwith an end portion diameter that allows the sealing member ring to beslid over the end portion and extending over an end portion distancefrom the end of the body, and having an intermediate portion with anintermediate portion diameter, greater than the sealing member ringinner diameter and extending an intermediate portion distance from theend portion; (c) a tip, with a hollow shaft in fluid communication witha combustion region of the tip, where the shaft has a first shaftdiameter that allows the shaft to be slid over the sealing member ringand extending a first distance from the end of the tip, and has a secondshaft diameter, lesser than the first shaft diameter and greater thanthe body end portion diameter, extending a second distance from the endof the tip; (d) where the first distance is greater than theintermediate portion distance by at least the height of the sealingmember ring cross-section; (e) where the seal is disposed around thebody end portion, proximal the location where the body intermediateportion begins, and seals between axial surfaces of the body end portionand the tip at the first shaft diameter, with the opening in theC-shaped cross-section facing toward the end of the body.
 2. Thepre-combustion chamber assembly of claim 1, wherein the cross-section isC-shaped.
 3. The pre-combustion chamber assembly of claim 1, wherein thethe second shaft diameter is greater than the body end portion outerdiameter sufficient to allow gas from the combustion portion to impingeon the open portion of the cross-section of the sealing member ring andurge the cross-section to expand and exert sealing force on the axialsurfaces of the body end portion and the shaft at the tip's first innerdiameter.
 4. The pre-combustion chamber assembly of claim 1, wherein thesealing member ring further comprises a spring disposed within thecross-section exerting force expanding the cross-section.
 5. Thepre-combustion chamber assembly of claim 1, wherein the body is groovedat the transition between the intermediate portion and the end portion,with the sealing member ring disposed in such groove.
 6. Thepre-combustion chamber assembly of claim 1, wherein the tip is chamferedat the transition in the shaft between the first shaft diameter and thesecond shaft diameter.
 7. The pre-combustion chamber assembly of claim 1wherein said sealing member ring comprises an engineered metal seal. 8.The seal pre-combustion chamber assembly of claim 1 wherein said sealingmember ring comprises an engineered metal seal with an energized spring.9. The pre-combustion chamber assembly of claim 1 wherein said sealingmember ring comprises a material including Inconel, Hastelloy, ortitanium alloys.
 10. A pre-combustion chamber tip for use with (a) asealing member ring having an inner diameter, a cross-section having awidth and a height, and an outer diameter equal to the inner diameterplus two times the width of the cross-section, where the cross-sectionis open in a direction perpendicular to a plane formed by the diameterof the ring; and (b) a body, having a cylindrical end portion with anend portion diameter that allows the sealing member ring to be slid overthe end portion and extending over an end portion distance from the endof the body, and having an intermediate portion with an intermediateportion diameter, greater than the sealing member ring inner diameterand extending an intermediate portion distance from the end portion;wherein the tip has a hollow shaft in fluid communication with acombustion region of the tip, where the shaft has a first shaft diameterthat allows the shaft to be slid over the sealing member ring andextending a first distance from the end of the tip, and has a secondshaft diameter, lesser than the first shaft diameter and greater thanthe body end portion diameter, extending a second distance from the endof the tip; where the first distance is greater than the intermediateportion distance by at least the height of the sealing member ringcross-section.